A modest proposal

For this discussion, you want to work as a reader response critic. Review the different types of reader response criticism and choose one to model when creating this discussion. Once you have chosen your style of reader response, create a discussion post that responds to the three different versions of Swift’s “A Modest Proposal.” How did your response change with each version? Which was your favorite? Why? You’ll want to work carefully to craft a discussion post that stays true to the kind of reader response you’ve chosen to practice here.Your initial post must be 75-100 words .

ANSWER

A Modest Proposal

Post

At that moment, Ireland’s political background gives the reader a more in-depth view of the British’s Swift, merciless whipping in all her colonies. Also, the British colonial government was sympathetic in a way that is reflected by her gentle words. In “A Modest Proposal,” the irony is highlighted by Swift’s suggestion that the problem of overpopulation is solved by eating babies. In reverse, the startling approach is to prove that landowners and their English masters are indeed cannibals. The article also became a thrilling indictment of British colonialism. It was a mild proposal, but it was a cruel, vicious, and outrageous proposition.

Comment 1

Swift passion expresses the darkness, corruption, and sins committed by the British empire. He also showed deep sympathy for the Irish government and lashed out at the backward feudal ideas of the people. To make it more convincing, he crunches numbers, cites statistics, even quotes, and quietly says the opposite. The irony was so vivid that some people believed what he said and denounced his cruelty, and he was mean to the point of admitting it to be irony.

Comment 2

In the proposal, Swift suggests that the body can be skinned and made into fitting sandals that men wear and fine-looking gloves worn by ladies. It is a chilling sounding reminder of the brutality and inhumanity of British colonial policy. The reason why the author’s article is hidden and meaningful is that it not only satirizes the ruler and his advisors but also arouses the ruler’s panic and shock. The use of many ironies in the text fully reflects Swift’s wit and humor irony. The use of irony throughout the article brought its acrimony to a climax.